Treatment of Foot Pain Caused by Plantar Fasciitis and Plantar Fasciosis.
|
Fig. 1: Ed Yourdon [CC BY-SA 2.0
'(https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/2.0)],
via Wikimedia Commons |
The
new year is here and many people are going to be starting new
exercise regimens as part of their resolutions. Some of those
starting exercise programs that involve running will develop pain on
the plantar surface of the foot (the bottom of the foot) and will
develop plantar fasciitis. If the pain persists, the condition may
well be reclassified as plantar fasciosis. This post will discuss
these two related conditions, will look at self-help techniques, and
will discuss treatment options with acupuncture, deep tissue massage,
and herbal therapy so that you can quickly get back to becoming more
fit in 2016.
|
Fig. 2: Image from: Sobotta's Atlas and
Text-book of Human Anatomy 1909.
This author uses the term Plantar
aponeurosis for Plantar fascia |
Plantar
fasciitis and plantar fasciosis are common pain syndromes involving
the plantar surface of the feet, and, since this problem affects us
when we are weight-bearing (standing, walking, running, etc.) it is
an especially annoying problem. This condition results in pain at the
attachment site of the plantar fascia to the calcaneus (heel) as seen in Fig. 2. One of
the hallmark symptoms of plantar fasciitis, at least in the early
stages, is pain with the first few steps in the morning or upon
rising after sitting for a long time, though it can become more
severe over time and the pain can persist during weight-bearing
activities.
First
off, it is important to understand the difference between plantar
fasciitis and plantar fasciosis. This is rarely discussed, even by
most physicians, but it is very important when considering treatment.
For plantar fasciitis, the suffix -itis means inflammation,
so this would imply that there is an inflammation of the plantar
fascia. In the very early stages of pain of the plantar fascia, this
could very well be the case. This would be especially evident if
someone starts a new exercise regimen that involves weight-bearing
activities such as running, jumping, martial arts, etc. Conventional
medical treatment might consist of corticosteroid injections or the
use of NSAIDs (non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs) to reduce the
inflammation. In my clinic I would consider a Traumeel injection
and/or would use herbal medications that have an anti-inflammatory
action. Other treatment strategies will be discussed below.
For
those suffering from chronic pain of the plantar fascia, the
inflammation model is likely not correct. There is a significant
amount of research now which shows that inflammatory cells are often
not present in these types of chronic pain conditions which affect
connective tissues such as tendons and aponeurotic structures (such
as the plantar fascia). Usually these signs of inflammation are no
longer present after about two to three weeks after the initial
tissue insult.
|
Fig. 3: Image modified from:
Phulvar (Own work) [CC BY-SA 3.0
(https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/3.0)],
via Wikimedia Commons |
Researchers
and, increasingly, some physicians are now referring to chronic pain
associated with the plantar fascia as plantar fasciosis. The suffix
-osis indicates a
diseased state, in this case involving a degenerative process which
results from a decreased blood flow to this tissue. This decreased
blood flow is caused by an increase in scar tissue and fibrosis
(fibrous tissue buildup) of the region. For these chronic cases,
breaking up this scar tissue and actually causing a mild inflammation
in the area is necessary to bring an adequate supply of blood to the
region. Acupuncture and deep tissue massage techniques such as
myofascial release are very effective for accomplishing this,
especially when combined.
|
Fig. 4: Deep myofascial release to the attachment of the plantar fascia. Very little to no lotion is used and the a slow gliding movement is used to break up fibrous adhesions. This is especially effective after acupuncture. |
In
either case, whether the pain is acute or chronic, the localized
treatments described above are just one aspect of recovery from these
painful conditions. It is crucial to look at strain and tension
patterns in the legs, especially the calves, and it is also necessary
to look at how weight transmits through the foot.
|
Fig. 5: Foot overpronation. This image also
illustrates inhibition of the gluteus medius
and minimus leading to an elevated right ilium.
Due to this, the knee moves in during weight
bearing and the foot overpronates. |
Over-pronation
(a collapse into the medial arch of the foot) is a common
contributing factor. In addition, restriction in the muscles of the
calf (the gastrocnemius and soleus) are very often contributing
factors. When these muscles are restricted, they transmit too much
pull on the Achilles tendon during walking, which prevents proper
ankle movement and requires the foot to undergo too much movement to
make up the difference, therefore overstretching and irritating the
plantar fascia.
Stretching
these calf muscles to return proper flexibility can be very helpful
for plantar fasciitis. Improving flexibility here allows proper ankle
movement and takes the strain off the plantar fascia. Besides this,
the calf muscles are continuous with the plantar fascia via their
fibrous connective tissue components. These muscles and the plantar
fascia are on the same fascial plane, so increasing flexibility and
suppleness in the muscles will reinforce an increase in suppleness at
the plantar fascia.
For
chronic cases, self-massage can be a helpful tool. I give a very
simple, yet useful, self-help technique to patients suffering from
plantar fasciitis. When waking in the morning, but before getting out
of bed and stepping on the foot, I recommend using the thumb to
perform a circular massage at the attachment of the plantar fascia to
the calcaneus (heel bone). This is the most common site of pain and
inflammation; the goal of this circular massage is to warm up and
create suppleness in the plantar fascia before putting an abrupt and
forceful motion through it by stepping on the foot. For many people,
doing this every morning (and even after sitting for several hours)
is very helpful. However, for more recalcitrant pain and dysfunction,
this will not be enough and other measures need to be looked at.
A
combination of acupuncture and deep myofascial release to these and
related regions yields excellent results and is often necessary when
dealing with the pain associated with plantar fasciitis. If it is
painful to stand and walk, exercise becomes difficult and people
become more sedentary, leading to other health complications. It is
essential to deal with this problem so that you can do all the things
that are important to you and start your new year off right.
Note: In Sports Medicine Acupuncture® we first assess the
condition to see if it is truly plantar fasciitis. There are many
other conditions which can cause pain in this region and they need to
be ruled out. Included are tarsal tunnel syndrome and tibialis posterior tendinopathy. Proper treatment of these conditions will be much more
successful if the condition can be properly diagnosed.